How to Get a Bad Review: Vacation Rental Mistakes to Avoid

How to Get a Bad Review: Vacation Rental Mistakes to Avoid 

The Do’s and Don’ts of Running a Vacation Rental in Treasure Island

Avoid these real mistakes—and protect your investment
(Featuring insights from Lockhart & Walseth Real Estate)

Why Treasure Island?

With over 3.5 million annual visitors to Pinellas County and a 12% year-over-year increase in short-term rental interest on platforms like Airbnb and VRBO, Treasure Island has become one of Florida’s most profitable Gulf Coast vacation rental zones.

Key Market Stats for 2025:

-Median short-term rental purchase price: $730,000

-Condos available under $500,000: 60+ active listings

-Average nightly rental rate for beachfront homes: $250–$350

-Median gross monthly rental income (properly managed): $3,000–$5,000

Real Mistakes from a Real Airbnb

What Not to Do

No TV in the Living Room
Guests expect a central space to relax and unwind. This property had no TV in the living room and only a small 25-inch screen in one bedroom.

Non-Functional Lighting
A decorative lamp was placed in a corner, but it wasn't plugged in—and no outlet was nearby. Guests notice when functionality is overlooked.

Missing Smoke Detector
The ceiling mount was there, but the actual detector was missing. Not only does this risk safety, but it also violates basic rental codes.

No Window Coverings
Bedrooms had no blinds or curtains. Privacy is essential and missing this detail can result in poor reviews.

Wet and Musty Rugs
One room had a soaking wet rug with a noticeable mildew smell. Cleanliness and freshness are the first things guests notice when they walk in.

What to Do Instead

Walk Through the Property Like a Guest
Sit on the couch, plug in lights, test the Wi-Fi, check every outlet, and assess the space as if you were paying to stay there.

Focus on Function Before Style
Aesthetic staging is nice, but it’s meaningless if the amenities don’t work. Prioritize livability.

Ensure Cleanliness and Comfort
Rugs should be dry, linens should smell clean, and every room should feel inviting and fresh. First impressions matter.

Cover Every Window
Bedrooms should have blinds or curtains for privacy and light control. This is a non-negotiable in short-term rentals.

Include Essential Amenities
A functioning TV in the main room, working smoke detectors, a basic kitchen setup, and reliable internet are minimum standards in today’s rental market.

How Lockhart & Walseth Can Help

Based in the heart of Treasure Island, Lockhart & Walseth Real Estate specializes in helping buyers and investors:

-Find short-term rental–friendly properties

-Analyze income potential based on market data and occupancy trends

-Identify potential red flags before you buy

-Coordinate with local vendors for repairs, staging, and pre-listing prep

-Maximize property value and guest satisfaction through smart upgrades

Client Example:
One client purchased a $485,000 condo on Gulf Blvd with our guidance. After staging and minor upgrades, the unit now generates an average of $3,200/month through short-term rentals, with a 90% occupancy rate during peak season.

Treat Your Rental Like a Business

A vacation rental isn’t just a property—it’s a brand. Guests will judge everything from your photos to the smell of the room the moment they walk in. One bad review can drastically lower your booking rate, so consistency is key.

Ready to Launch Your Vacation Rental?

Whether you're buying your first investment property or upgrading an existing listing, Lockhart & Walseth can help you navigate the Treasure Island market with expert insight.

-Visit us: 10681 Gulf Blvd #2, Treasure Island, FL

-Call for a consultation on short-term rental opportunities

Watch our full Airbnb walkthrough :

How to get a bad review and Vacation Rental Mistakes

Lockhart & Walseth Real Estate
Local Expertise. Investor Focus. Consistently Five-Star Results.